Nautilus R616 Vs. Schwinn 270: Recumbent Bike Comparison

Recumbent bikes are an excellent way to stay mentally and physically fit, especially during the winter seasons! The Nautilus and Schwinn companies have both designed a recumbent bike that exceeds expectations for those in the market for home fitness equipment. This review will cover the similarities and differences between these two machines.

Feature

Nautilus R616

Schwinn 270

Preview

Nautilus Recumbent Bike Series

SCHWINN 270 Recumbent Bike

Drive System

Fast-paced and intense drive system with a flywheel that is weighted around its perimeter (Winner)

Fast-paced and intense drive system with a flywheel that is weighted around its perimeter (Winner)

Noise Level

Extremely quiet
(Winner)

Extremely quiet
(Winner)

Seat

Cushioned seat with large backrest with big holes for ventilation

Cushioned seat with large backrest and small holes for comfortability and ventilation (Winner)

Price

Slightly more expensive

 Less expensive
(Winner)

Weight

91.9 Lbs.

86.6 Lbs.
Lighter weight means easier to move around the home
(Winner)

Warranty

Frame: 10 years
Electronics: 3 years
Parts: 3 Years
Labor: 1 year
(Winner)

Frame: 10 years
Electronics: 1 year
Parts: 2 years
Labor: 90 days

Check Price

Exercise Bike Features We Considered

The Schwinn 270 and Nautilus R616 are very similar recumbent bikes. Below we will identify similarities and build quality of the machines. Each user has different fitness goals, and we are here to help you pick the right machine for your specific needs.

Who doesn’t want to maintain their physical and mental best? When shopping for your particular needs, this side-by-side comparison will help narrow down your choice.

Build Quality

It's essential to choose a high-quality material to ensure the longevity of your exercise bike, and steel is the best option for high-end bikes. The build quality of the Nautilus R616 and the Schwinn 270 are basically identical.

Max User Weight & Height

Consider who will be riding the bike before purchasing and ensure that the weight capacity is suitable for your body weight and any additional weights you plan to use during your workout. Both of these recumbent bikes are suitable to heights between 4’11” and 6’3”, with a max weight of 300 lbs.

Footprint & Transportability

The footprint is the length and width of the base of the bike. Look at the rooms in your home and decide on a space for the bike before purchasing. Make sure that the bike will fit in the measured space. Transport wheels are a good idea for homeowners who want to be able to move their bike from room to room.

Resistance Mechanism & Exercise Levels

Both bikes have a fast-paced and high-intensity flywheel that runs on magnetic resistance. They each come with 25 resistance levels as well. We like the magnetic resistance mechanism the best because it offers a smooth, comfortable ride while transitioning between resistance levels.

This is the best option for exercisers who want to workout with HIIT programs and will need to quickly adjust resistance levels while working out.

Comfort & Adjustability

The Schwinn as well as the Nautilus have well-cushioned seats and ventilated backrests. They also have similar handlebars with extra-grip for balance. Look for a bike with a comfortable, cushioned seat so that you won’t tire of riding. Uncomfortable, hard seats can hurt your behind and make you want to stop riding before your full workout is finished.

Assembly

If you are not a handy person, we recommend looking at assembly instructions before purchasing. Some bikes are easier to put together than others.  According to reviews, it seems that the Schwinn is much easier to assemble than the Nautilus. Troubleshooting and maintenance manuals can be found on their direct websites.

Price Guide

How affordable do you want your bike to be? Do you have a large budget and want the best? Or would you prefer a solid, budget buy? The Nautilus is a bit more expensive than the Schwinn model. 

Quiet & Smooth Operation

Both machines have a similar drive system and flywheel and are built to operate smoothly and quietly in the home. The drive system is one of the most important factors when it comes to the sound and movement of the bike. Look for a large, well made flywheel for the quietest option.

Integration with Different Tech

These recumbent bikes both come with Bluetooth capabilities, heart rate pulse sensors on the handlebars, and are compatible with fitness apps. We recommend choosing a bike that connects with a fitness app or Bluetooth device if you want to be challenged. These apps can also be a great way to connect with friends and family.

Warranty Length

Check the warranty length before purchasing. Most bikes should have a one-year warranty for parts and electronics with a 5-10 year warranty for the frame.

Extra Features

What extra features do you need? Some bikes come with built-in fans, water bottle holders, tablet trays, and additional workout programs. Consider what bike accessories would make for a more enjoyable exercise experience for you.


Side-by-Side Comparison: Nautilus R616 vs. Schwinn 270

Durability & Build Quality

These machines both have an incredibly similar build quality and durability record. They are sturdy and made from a high-quality steel and structured with intense-use in mind. You can’t go wrong with either, and they will both last users a long time.

User Weight & Height Needs

The height range is the exact same on both models. They are both listed as well-suited for users between four-foot-eleven and six-foot-three. The weight capacity on both machines is also up to 300 lbs. Be sure to keep this in mind if you plan to use barbell weights while using the machine.

Size of Unit & Portability

The Nautilus is slightly smaller than the Schwinn, but not by much. Be sure to measure the space in your home where you plan to place your new fitness machine. Each machine also comes with transport wheels, which are designed to help the user move the machine around their home without hired help.

Workout Programs & Resistance Levels

Both the Schwinn and the Nautilus have 29 preset workout programs and 25 resistance levels, giving users various fitness challenges to choose from. The Nautilus's programs are: 12 profile, nine heart rate, one recovery test, one quick start, two fitness tests, and four custom-designable programs.

The Schwinn's programs are: 12 profile, nine heart rate, one recovery test, two fitness tests, four customizable programs, and one quick-start program.

Seat & Handles

Both recumbent bikes have similar seats. They have very comfortable seat cushions. However, there is one significant difference; the backrests. The Schwinn 270 has received praise for its comfortable backrest, and we believe this is because of the small holes for ventilation.

They are small enough to allow air to flow through, but not too large, which would cause discomfort. The Nautilus R616 has large holes for ventilation, and many comments suggest the seat digs into your back. Handles are both ultra-gripped for stability in mounting and dismounting the bike.

Assembly & Maintenance

Maintenance and assembly manuals are available on the Schwinn website and the Nautilus website. This is a helpful tool as some users found assembly and maintenance issues. Commenters revealed frustration when discussing their difficulty in assembling the Nautilus R616.

They felt there were issues with connecting the wires and the manual wasn’t the easiest to follow at times. The Schwinn 270, however, has had raving reviews about ease of assembly as well as a lack of maintenance issues.

Value for Money

Both machines are an excellent value for their cost. While the Nautilus is listed at a lower price on their website, there are slight differences that may make this cost difference understandable. They are incredibly affordable compared to most similar machines on the market.

Noise Levels

You can be sure of a quiet experience when purchasing the Schwinn 270 or the Nautilus R616. Reviewers raved about both machines being quieter than a mouse. We love that regardless of which machine you choose, you can be sure that working out at two in the morning won't result in waking up anyone in the house.

Compatibility with Tech

The Nautilus R616 and the Schwinn 270 are compatible with the Explore the World app (subscriptions not included.) They are also compatible with fitness tracking apps like MyFitnessPal and can connect to these apps through the included Bluetooth connectivity.

Warranty

As seen in the previous section, the Nautilus has a slightly better warranty on the labor, electronics, and parts. This may be a deciding factor in equipment purchase. They are both the same with ten years for the frame. Usually, the cheaper the bike, the weaker the warranty, so we love that Nautilus is both more affordable and has a more impressive warranty.


Schwinn 270 & Nautilus R616 Recumbent Bikes Compared

Feature

Schwinn 270

Nautilus R616

Resistance Type

Magnetic

Magnetic

Resistance Levels

25

25

Display

DualTrack LCD

DualTrack LCD

Bluetooth Connectivity

Yes

Yes

Preset Exercise Programs

29

29

Crank System

3-piece pedal cranks

3-piece pedal cranks

Number of Users

4

4

Warranty

Yes

Yes

Dimensions

64” L x 27.7” W x 49.9” H

65.3" L x 28.3" W x 49.6" H

Item Weight

86.6 lbs.

91.9 lbs.


Pros of These Recumbent Exercise Bikes

What We Like

Schwinn 270
  • Bluetooth and App connectivity
  • Offers fitness challenges
  • Padded seat
  • Ventilated backrest
  • USB port
  • Lightweight
Nautilus R616
  • Bluetooth and App connectivity
  • Offers fitness challenges
  • Padded seat
  • Ventilated backrest
  • USB port
  • Great Warranty

Cons of These Recumbent Exercise Bikes

What We Didn’t Like

Schwinn 270
  • Short labor warranty
  • Inconsistent pulse grip
  • Quiet speakers
Nautilus R616
  • Inconsistent pulse grip
  • Uncomfortable backrest
  • Weak fan

Assembling & Using These Recumbent Bikes

Both user manuals are conveniently available on their direct websites. To start us out, the Schwinn 270 Recumbent Bike User Manual provides a helpful step-by-step guide. First, you will want to make sure that you have all your pieces and tools (screws, washers, and wrenches) laid out in front of you.

Always use the tools recommended. When attaching any pieces together, just make sure they are properly aligned so that they can be inserted correctly and safely. Assembly may require two people. Assembly should take about an hour.

The Nautilus R616 User Manual also provides helpful step-by-step instructions. First, be sure to lay out all the pieces and tools (screws, washers, and wrenches) in front of you. Assemble this machine on a level surface.

Plus, the machine in after assembly and ensure the pedals are stable before you step on them. When attaching pieces, be sure they are attached evenly and precisely. Assembly may require two people. Assembly should take about an hour and a half.

For both machines, you will want to download the connecting apps on your device and turn on Bluetooth on the recumbent bike as well as your device. When you open the app, it should connect. Try Explore the World for cycling and MyFitnessPal for fitness tracking!


People Also Ask (FAQs)

Where can I get Schwinn recumbent bike parts? Does it come with any replacement parts when you order it?

You can buy Schwinn replacement bike parts directly on their website. We also highly recommend finding them on Amazon, but be sure the seller has a great history and rating!

What are the essential accessories that I need to buy together with the recumbent bike?

These recumbent bikes come with everything you need. However, if you would like to improve upon comfortability, we suggest buying an additional back cushion. You can also look into mats to protect the floor in your home.

How much should I spend on a recumbent bike?

We recommend spending whatever you can comfortably afford. If you are on a budget, there are many incredible recumbent bikes under $1000.

Are Nautilus and Schwinn the same company?

Bowflex actually bought Nautilus and Schwinn, so they are technically owned by the same company, yes.

Where is the best place to buy these recumbent bikes?

Amazon is the best place to purchase your Nautilus R616 or Schwinn 270 machines. They often have discounts and deals on shipping. We also highly recommend purchasing directly from the Schwinn website and Nautilus website.


Conclusion

You genuinely cannot go wrong with purchasing either one of these incredible recumbent bikes. The Nautilus R616 is great for those on a budget who would prefer a longer warranty. And the Schwinn 270 is great for families and those with back comfort in mind. These fitness machines will, without a doubt, exceed all your expectations!